Classic · A landmark paper, revisited
Weak selection can lose to chance
Ohta T. Slightly deleterious mutant substitutions in evolution. Nature 246:96–98 (1973). Original paper.
Ohta extended neutral theory by arguing that some mutations are mildly harmful yet can still spread through random genetic drift. Whether selection efficiently removes them depends on effective population size and the magnitude of their fitness effects. A mutation that is consistently eliminated in a large population may behave almost neutrally in a small one. Her 1973 paper assembled molecular observations and population-genetic arguments suggesting that slightly deleterious substitutions could be especially important in small populations and around speciation. The resulting nearly neutral framework remains central to interpreting molecular evolution, mutation accumulation and differences in the efficacy of selection across lineages.